Best of Econtwitter

Share this post

Best of #econtwitter - Week of March 26, 2023: interesting tweets

www.bestofecontwitter.com

Best of #econtwitter - Week of March 26, 2023: interesting tweets

Mar 27, 2023
1
Share this post

Best of #econtwitter - Week of March 26, 2023: interesting tweets

www.bestofecontwitter.com
Share

Welcome readers old and new to this week’s edition of Best of Econtwitter. Please submit suggestions — very much including your own work! — over email or on Twitter @just_economics.

Interesting discussions

Twitter avatar for @ipogadog
Gopi Shah Goda @ipogadog
Citations are often "currency" for academics. While not perfect, they provide a meaningful measure of academic impact, are easy to obtain, and heavily influence academic promotions. But how do we measure the broader impact of scholarly work? Some thoughts… 1/
10:51 PM ∙ Mar 23, 2023
46Likes6Retweets
Twitter avatar for @heidilwilliams_
Heidi L. Williams @heidilwilliams_
@MichaelEddy @ipogadog This is a great paper, but to give credit to a key source of the underlying data they use let me add a cite to @overtonio:
overton.ioHomepage - OvertonIs your work influencing policy? We help universities, think tanks and publishers understand the reach and influence of their research Track your policy impact Overton is the world’s largest searchable index of policy documents, guidelines, think tank publications and working papers. It collects dat…
4:58 PM ∙ Mar 24, 2023
Twitter avatar for @MaxGhenis
Max Ghenis @MaxGhenis
Friends, colleagues, may I present to you: the California Marginal Tax Rate Schedule
Image
3:13 AM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
2,281Likes232Retweets
Twitter avatar for @MaxGhenis
Max Ghenis @MaxGhenis
@StatisticsFTW Yes, though we model TANF in California and not those states (for now--we're working on it in NY and TX). That explains California's increase and spike at the low end. CA policyengine.org/us/household?f… TX policyengine.org/us/household?f… FL policyengine.org/us/household?f… NY policyengine.org/us/household?f…
Image
Image
Image
Image
4:51 AM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
73Likes3Retweets

^🤢

Twitter avatar for @MaxGhenis
Max Ghenis @MaxGhenis
If this single parent of two in California earns $10k, they take home $38k. If they earn $50k, they take home $49k. That's a 73% marginal tax rate over a $40,000 earnings range. And that's without childcare and housing subsidies!
Image
3:13 AM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
499Likes48Retweets
Twitter avatar for @itaisher
Itai Sher @itaisher
When I teach preference relations, one thing I always emphasize is the difference between indifference and incomparability, that is, between not not caring and being unable to decide. It’s a very important distinction.
6:44 PM ∙ Mar 26, 2023
66Likes2Retweets

^file under: completeness axiom is overrated

Twitter avatar for @taylor_wright
Taylor John Wright @taylor_wright
I really like John's adaptation and I try to set goals like "write an article that is good enough to be published in X journal" rather than "publish this article in journal X". Your paper's quality is something you control (for the most part) whereas
Twitter avatar for @johnjhorton
John Horton @johnjhorton
I debate tweeting this, but I do feel esp. young researchers should know the publication game is a tough one. Lots of noise. Lots of bad opinions masquerading as objective eval. My adaptation is to try to focus on the work and the research and not be so focused on the journal
11:29 AM ∙ Mar 24, 2023
17Likes1Retweet
Twitter avatar for @johnjhorton
John Horton @johnjhorton
@StefanFSchubert I also try to put a lot of effort into trying to make results as clear and simple as I possibly can, which I think maximizes long-run impact but I suspect hurts in the short run because it makes what you're doing seem not very impressive
11:08 AM ∙ Mar 24, 2023
Twitter avatar for @matt_blackwell
Matt Blackwell @matt_blackwell
If I could give a single piece of advice to new PhD students (in poli sci at least): work as hard as you can to write a complete, submittable solo research article by the time you start your 3rd year. Even if it is never published, the experience you get is insanely helpful
1:20 AM ∙ Mar 26, 2023
499Likes67Retweets
Twitter avatar for @jamieson
Dave Jamieson @jamieson
This is demented wsj.com/articles/that-…
Image
2:03 PM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
18,713Likes5,277Retweets
Twitter avatar for @BrettMatsumoto
B.M. @BrettMatsumoto
This article in the WSJ starts by citing the number of job openings in JOLTS, then talks about a bunch of sketchy job listing practices but fails to note that these wouldn't (or at least shouldn't) be counted as job openings in JOLTS:
wsj.comJob Listings Abound, but Many Are FakeIn an uncertain economy, companies post ads for jobs that they might not really be trying to fill.
10:08 PM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
42Likes10Retweets

AI

Wake up!

Twitter avatar for @finmoorhouse
Fin Moorhouse @finmoorhouse
In Jan of this year, @bryan_caplan bet @MatthewJBar that no AI would reliably score an A on his economics midterm exams before 2029. Three *months* later, GPT-4 scores an A.
Image
Image
4:49 PM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
499Likes81Retweets
Twitter avatar for @ben_levinstein
Ben Levinstein @ben_levinstein
Somehow missed this the first time I looked, but GPT-4 got *significantly worse* at microeconomics after it was trained to tell you what you want to hear.
Image
1:44 PM ∙ Mar 22, 2023
1,880Likes204Retweets
Twitter avatar for @jamesbrandecon
Jimbo Brand @jamesbrandecon
Today's fun GPT+Econ exercise: asking it to develop example code for structural estimation from a description + latex equations. The goal was to get it to give me a function that could estimate an approximate mixed-logit model. Step 1: ask GPT-4 how best to structure my prompt
Image
7:22 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
95Likes18Retweets
Twitter avatar for @ModeledBehavior
Adam Ozimek @ModeledBehavior
Can’t wait until someone integrates chatGPT with all the census and BLS APIs.
12:21 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
70Likes4Retweets
Twitter avatar for @adatta02
Ashish Datta @adatta02
@ModeledBehavior Check out
censusgpt.comCensus GPTSearch the census database with natural language
12:28 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
20Likes2Retweets
Twitter avatar for @MushtaqBilalPhD
Mushtaq Bilal, PhD @MushtaqBilalPhD
Don't use ChatGPT for academic research. It creates fake citations to papers that don't even exist. Instead, use Consensus — an AI-powered search engine designed for academics. Ask it a question and it'll give you a summary of top 5-10 (real) published papers.
8:10 AM ∙ Mar 26, 2023
57,393Likes12,295Retweets

^haven’t tried this one yet honestly but

Journals and political endorsements

Twitter avatar for @Nature
nature @Nature
In 2020, Nature endorsed Joe Biden in the US presidential election. A survey finds that viewing the endorsement did not change people’s views of the candidates, but caused some to lose confidence in Nature and in US scientists generally
go.nature.comPolitical endorsements can affect scientific credibilityEndorsing Joe Biden caused Trump supporters to trust Nature less.
10:20 PM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
5,377Likes984Retweets
Twitter avatar for @DouthatNYT
Ross Douthat @DouthatNYT
Ah, but I see they officially have no regrets:
nature.comShould Nature endorse political candidates? Yes — when the occasion demands itPolitical endorsements might not always win hearts and minds, but when candidates threaten a retreat from reason, science must speak out.
1:06 PM ∙ Mar 21, 2023
106Likes10Retweets
Twitter avatar for @ben_golub
Ben Golub 🇺🇦 @ben_golub
This, from the Editor of Science, is so disappointing. Not because I embrace a naive separation between values and facts. No: because it's a profound waste of the precious institutions of Nature and Science for them to focus on the same dumb political axis as everyone else.
Twitter avatar for @hholdenthorp
Holden Thorp, Science EIC @hholdenthorp
In light of @Nature's excellent editorial about why it makes sense to comment on politics (all the way, in their case, to making an endorsement), this is the Pew finding that is most relevant. Following the admonition to stick to science is conceding 1/n https://t.co/1jcwWSsBDs
9:20 PM ∙ Mar 22, 2023
261Likes24Retweets
Twitter avatar for @RuxandraTeslo
Ruxandra Maria 🧬🦭✨ @RuxandraTeslo
I don’t think the purpose of academia is to achieve justice. The purpose of academia is to get closer to the truth Doctors should treat a patient independently of their moral failings (they should cure a murderer); Academics shouldn’t cast moral judgements on their findings
12:18 PM ∙ Dec 12, 2022
827Likes76Retweets

^could put this tweet in the newsletter every other week

Twitter avatar for @FloydZhang93
Floyd Zhang @FloydZhang93
I appreciate that @Nature's editorial board responded to my research graciously and promptly. The discussion of my paper offered is thoughtful, but I find the counter-arguments and the conclusion unconvincing. (1/n)🧵
Twitter avatar for @Nature
nature @Nature
Editorial: Political endorsements might not always win hearts and minds, but when candidates threaten a retreat from reason, science must speak out https://t.co/tOSdHfFpWe
3:33 AM ∙ Mar 22, 2023
206Likes49Retweets

AI safety

Twitter avatar for @Jabaluck
Jason Abaluck @Jabaluck
What regulatory options make sense to reduce risk from AI? My tentatively preferred option is to allocate at least $100 billion a year or more for rewards and grants for AI safety innovations, assessed by a board of relevant CEOs and AI researchers (i.e. people with inside info).
4:32 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
192Likes32Retweets
Twitter avatar for @Jabaluck
Jason Abaluck @Jabaluck
The problems you might have thought would take decades or centuries for AIs to solve are already being solved:
Twitter avatar for @leopoldasch
Leopold Aschenbrenner @leopoldasch
Common sense: https://t.co/MUmFV1yo8m
4:32 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
Twitter avatar for @leopoldasch
Leopold Aschenbrenner @leopoldasch
AI safety becoming mainstream (Good thread from Yale econ professor)
Twitter avatar for @Jabaluck
Jason Abaluck @Jabaluck
What regulatory options make sense to reduce risk from AI? My tentatively preferred option is to allocate at least $100 billion a year or more for rewards and grants for AI safety innovations, assessed by a board of relevant CEOs and AI researchers (i.e. people with inside info).
4:38 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
66Likes3Retweets
Twitter avatar for @alexoimas
Alex Imas @alexoimas
Many are talking about the existential risk of AI, where humanity is “wiped out”. I think more likely risk is AI used by corporations to supercharge the exploitation human biases, leading to extreme polarization and isolation. Think Wall-E & Tokyo Ghost, not terminator. 1/4
3:05 PM ∙ Mar 26, 2023
152Likes28Retweets
Twitter avatar for @sc_cath
Sylvain Catherine @sc_cath
Right, and to some extent, this is a risk that is not specific to AI. Drugs, sugar, alcohol have already destroyed some societies... while other have developed ways to control the dangers of these products and get the best of them. Same thing here, we need to sort out new norms
Twitter avatar for @alexoimas
Alex Imas @alexoimas
Many are talking about the existential risk of AI, where humanity is “wiped out”. I think more likely risk is AI used by corporations to supercharge the exploitation human biases, leading to extreme polarization and isolation. Think Wall-E & Tokyo Ghost, not terminator. 1/4
9:45 PM ∙ Mar 26, 2023
9Likes2Retweets

Public goods

Twitter avatar for @moritzmarbach
Moritz Marbach @moritzmarbach
Finding regional / sub-national data in 🇪🇺 is often challenging. I am compiling a list of databases with regional data from statistical agencies across Europe and the corresponding R packages. Please add to this Google Sheet if you know any: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…
docs.google.comRegional Data in Europe | National DatabasesList Group,Country,Name of Agency,Website of Agency,Agency Database with Regional Data,Corresponding R Package,Other Database(s) with Regional Data,Corresponding R package(s),Comments EFTA,Iceland,Statistics Iceland,<a href=“http://www.statice.is/”>http://www.statice.is/</a>,<a href=“https://px....
3:29 PM ∙ Mar 22, 2023
226Likes60Retweets

Fin

Twitter avatar for @curiouswavefn
Ash Jogalekar @curiouswavefn
This recollection of Ed Witten's early career by a friend from his college days is really something. It shows that even geniuses can meander and flounder quite a bit before making a mark.
Image
1:32 AM ∙ Mar 24, 2023
980Likes202Retweets
Twitter avatar for @Jabaluck
Jason Abaluck @Jabaluck
The moral: if you're meandering and floundering, don't worry -- your goal-directed, child prodigy classmates might have been famous physicists in the past, but now they will likely be supplanted by super-intelligent AIs, albeit with an uncertain timeline.
5:23 PM ∙ Mar 24, 2023
Twitter avatar for @arthur_spirling
Arthur Spirling @arthur_spirling
What’s funny about this is that you can, without needing the labels, immediately tell which line must represent the most popular choice for academics seeking engagement with the world.
Image
6:43 PM ∙ Mar 25, 2023
312Likes32Retweets

^but:

Twitter avatar for @_AlvinChristian
Alvin Christian @_AlvinChristian
Twitter can be a big time sink and toxic sometimes, but it can also be useful and enriching. For instance, this week I'm going to a conference to present on a paper I wrote inspired by a @johnjhorton tweet!
Twitter avatar for @_AlvinChristian
Alvin Christian @_AlvinChristian
This is really cool. 1) Ppl generally have a good sense of what pre-K/K teachers earn but less so for Elementary/Middle/HS. 2) Ppl really underestimate how much teachers earn - I wonder if some staffing challenges can be addressed by just giving folks more info in HS/college? https://t.co/nov8vEOUxl https://t.co/uJvezczBqg
8:31 PM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
46Likes2Retweets
Twitter avatar for @nathancofnas
Nathan Cofnas @nathancofnas
Out of the 20 most interesting thinkers *under the age of 45*, how many are currently employed by universities?
5:12 PM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
18Likes5Retweets

^🤔

Twitter avatar for @ollyrobot
o||y @ollyrobot
i am outside. it rains, i get soaked. “haha, revealed preferences” i say. i get sick, and lose my job, because i cant work. “revealed preferences”, i murmur, my intellectual might intact. my landlord evicts me, i beg on the street. my sign reads “this is my revealed preference”
11:59 AM ∙ Mar 20, 2023
362Likes30Retweets
1
Share this post

Best of #econtwitter - Week of March 26, 2023: interesting tweets

www.bestofecontwitter.com
Share
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 An Economist
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing